Skip to main content

Habhae saak koorraavae ddithae: Love Without Safety Is Not Love

On average, couples date for three to five years before marriage. For me, getting to know my husband began after we were married.

Three months after our first meeting in 1993, I married the man I believed was the love of my life. At the time, this was not unusual in the Sikh Punjabi community. Long courtships were rare, and marriage itself was often the place where love was expected to grow. Everything appeared aligned; faith, family, careers, values. What felt like a bold leap of faith, however, began to tilt toward uncertainty soon after the wedding.

I stayed through the first five years because I believed in what we had begun. There were moments of connection, hope, and genuine affection. I wanted to believe that with time, understanding would deepen and challenges would soften. Living in a joint family initially felt like support, but over time I realized it also masked what was breaking between us. The presence of others filled the space where intimacy should have been, camouflaging the growing distance. I stayed because I hoped that love, family involvement, and patience could fix what was quietly unraveling.

During those early years, our three children were born. As our family grew, so did the imbalance. Looking back, I can see that the abuse has already begun; the control disguised as concern, manipulation framed as authority, anger justified as discipline. In 1999, after a major crisis and my ultimatum to leave, my husband began attending anger-management classes. I stayed again. It was not the life I had imagined, but I believed effort meant progress.

Over time, my reason for staying shifted. Protecting my children became my primary concern. I feared that leaving would expose them to his unpredictable behavior without my presence as a buffer. Staying under the same roof, though deeply painful, felt like the lesser evil. It allowed me to shield them, to absorb the volatility myself rather than leave them alone with it during court-ordered visitations. I stayed because I believed that my proximity was their protection. I told myself that having both parents, even in a broken marriage, was better than the alternative. I would later understand how flawed that belief was. But at the time, it was a decision rooted in fear and maternal instinct, not weakness.

After few years, I stepped away from my career to become a stay-at-home mother. It felt like the right choice for my children. I wanted to be present, vigilant, available. But that decision also tethered me financially and delayed my exit. Over time, the idea of rebuilding a career felt overwhelming. Leaving no longer meant just escaping abuse; it meant starting life over from the ground up, with no financial footing and three children depending on me.

As I began the slow process of reestablishing my career, another challenge emerged. Our older daughter began struggling with her mental health. I had no framework, no language, and no understanding of what we were facing. Watching her suffer without answers added a new layer of fear to an already fragile life. I was navigating her needs while still managing a home steeped in tension. The emotional weight was relentless.

Eight more years passed. Years spent searching for a diagnosis, learning through exhaustion, and living in constant uncertainty. Time blurred. Hope thinned. I wondered if this was simply our fate.

Then the pandemic arrived.

COVID stripped away distractions and distance. Forced proximity exposed truths I could no longer deny. In the isolation and stillness, I finally understood that I did not have to keep living this way. Survival was no longer enough.

In the fall of 2022, our older daughter became ill again. It was terrifying. As I began learning more about mental illness and defense mechanisms such as projection, another truth emerged alongside that knowledge. I started to see her father’s long-standing anger and abusive patterns through a clearer lens. In April 2023, during one of the most fragile moments of my parenting life , when our daughter needed steadiness and care above all else, I found myself without support. After a night in which we had spoken about setting aside our differences to focus on her well-being, the following morning brought accusations and a tone that made it clear trust and emotional safety were no longer intact. There was also a quiet awareness, long present in the background, that added to my unease. In that moment, clarity arrived; not gradually, but decisively. I understood that staying was no longer protective, and that realization landed with the weight of a physical blow.

For the first time, I understood that he, too, was deeply unwell; living with an undiagnosed mental illness that shaped his anger, lack of empathy, and inability to repair. This realization brought conflicting emotions; compassion for the suffering he never addressed, and grief for the damage it caused. Understanding explained his behavior; but it did not excuse it.

I reached a breaking point. Our daughter had already lost the steady presence of her siblings because of his behavior. Now, she needed them and she needed me. Fully. Strong, clear, and unwavering. For her to heal, she needed safety. Stability. A home free from fear and chaos. I made the most painful decision of my life. I chose my child over my marriage.It took me five days to secure a place to go and gather only what was essential. On the fifth morning, at Amrit Vela, I loaded my car with a single suitcase holding nearly three decades of life. I left quietly and arrived at a space that was empty, unfamiliar, and peaceful - a place I would begin to call home.

After nearly six months of suffering, I was finally able to get treatment for my daughter.

I left not because I stopped believing in family, not because I no longer valued commitment - our laavan, but because love without safety is not love. And staying would have cost my daughter her chance to heal and me my last remaining strength.

To my readers

When I decided to share my story of those years of the pandemic, the unraveling of my marriage, and the fractures within our family; I did not do so to assign blame or to seek validation. I shared it because silence had protected harm for too long, and truth, even when painful, is a form of dignity.For a long time, I believed that if I just tried harder, loved better, explained more gently, absorbed more pain, I could keep my family intact. I mistook endurance for strength. I mistook self-erasure for sacrifice. And like many women, especially mothers, I confused being “the glue” with being necessary. The truth is quieter and harder. No family can be held together by one person bleeding silently.

The most important shift did not come when people left, or when relationships went quiet. It came when I stopped calling fear “misunderstanding.” When I stopped asking my children to tolerate what I would never accept for them.

To the Ones Who See Themselves Here

If you are reading this and recognizing your own life between these lines, I want you to know this-

You are not weak for staying as long as you did.

You are not cruel for leaving when you did.

You are not failing your family by refusing to absorb harm.

Families do not fall apart because someone finally speaks. They fall apart when someone never listens.

Previous

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Uh jo chhote han na vaade

“………….but I want to do what I want to do”. The loud voice of ‘once’ sweet son, came from the family room as I asked him to turn the TV off and ‘practice’ that he learns after school and on weekends. I was not only shocked but almost in tears as this was not my same son who religiously followed the evening routine and took everything seriously that he learnt in extra curricular activities, along with his learning at school. Above all that he has been ‘Mama’s helper’ in tutoring his younger sister, passing on all the good stuff that he learnt to his sisters. Like his first-grade teacher still says about him "They don't come in better package than this one". I had no complaints and said prayer of gratitude for these children every morning and before going to bed. But what happened this last week? I don’t know except that I know he is going to celebrate his 12 th birthday in few weeks and he is growing. I think that is what they call adolescence. If I remember it right it is...

The Punjabi Garden - By Patricia Klindienst

Patricia Klindienst is a master gardener and an award-winning scholar and teacher. She lives in Guilford, Connecticut, and teaches creative writing each summer at Yale University. Excerpted from The Earth Knows My Name: Food, Culture, and Sustainability in the Gardens of Ethnic America, by Patricia Klindienst. Copyright © 2006 by Patricia Klindienst. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- A California gardener used the farming wisdom of her native India to create a suburban paradise that restored her soil--and sustains her soul. “I told my father, ‘I will be poorer in America, but my conscience will be free.’” I write the words on a paper napkin and turn it to face her. “Is this right? Is this what you just said?” “Yes. I did not come to America to trade my cultural heritage for money.” I take the napkin back and write the second sentence as well. Her words are so striking that I do not want to rely on memory al...

Violence against women: How Anger Destroys Families and What Gurbani Teaches Us

Note to the readers: I wrote this in 2009 and kept it tucked away. Coming back to it reminded me why I wrote it in the first place, and I’m glad to finally share it. November 25th is the international Day for the elimination of violence against women. This day was recognized by the General Assembly of United Nations in 1999 with a view too raising public awareness of violations of the rights of the women, why was this step deemed necessary? In many cultures women are viewed and treated as inferior or as second class citizens. Prejudices against them are deep rooted. Gender based violence is an on going problem even in the so-called developed world. According to former UN Secretary General Kofi Annan “Violence against women is global in reach, and takes place in all societies and cultures,” he said in a statement marking the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women. “It affects women no matter what their race, ethnicity, social origin, birth or other status may...